The Drinking Behaviors of a Sample of University Students in Nanning, Guangxi Province, People's Republic of China
Zhuo-Ping Lu,1 Ruth C. Engs,2,* and David J. Hanson3
1Guangxi Medical University, Nanning, People's Republic of China
2Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana, USA
3State University of New York, Potsdam, New York, USA
Lu, Zhuo-Ping, Engs, R. C. and Hanson, D.J. (1997) "The Drinking Behaviors of a Sample of University Students in Nanning, Guangxi Province, People's Republic of China." Substance Use and Misuse, 32(4), 495-506. https://scholarworks.iu.edu/dspace/handle/2022/17489
A Chinese translation of the Student Alcohol Questionnaire was administered to a sample of 190 students at two universities in Nanning, China. Males consumed alcohol significantly more frequently and in greater quantities than did females. A significantly higher proportion of males also experienced problems resulting from their drinking. Beer was the alcoholic beverage of choice for both males and females. Most students of both genders drank with friends, and most have also consumed with their parents; about half reported that their parents approved of their alcohol consumption. The results support earlier observations that moderate drinking is widely accepted in the Chinese culture and results in few problems.
Key words: University students; Drinking behaviors; Chinese
A variety of alcoholic beverages have been used in China since prehistoric times (Granet, 1957). They have been widely used in all segments of Chinese society as a source of inspiration, for hospitality, and as an antidote for fatigue (Samuelson, 1878; Fei-Peng, 1982).
The Chinese have long been recognized as a group that uses alcohol in moderation and that experiences very few drinking problems compared to North Americans and some Northern Europeans (Hsu, 1970; La Barre, 1946).
Recent studies of Chinese in China, Taiwan, Singapore, and the United States indicate that most consume alcohol in moderation, on special occasions, and where there are social controls on their drinking. Very few experience any drinking problems (Pai, 1991; Helzer et al., 1990; Chi, et al., 1988, 1989; Akutsu et al., 1989; Ahern, 1985; Yu et al., 1985; Yu and Liu, 1986/1987; Isralowitz and Hong, 1988; Kitano and Chi, 1985; LeMarchand et al., 1985; Sue et al., 1985). (See Table 1 for details of this literature.)
It is commonly known that males in western cultures drink much more frequently and in larger amounts than females. A few studies suggest that this is also found among Chinese cultureal groups (Sue et al., 1985; Yu et al., 1985). However, the differences between male and female drinking in Chinese culture may disappear with age (Weatherspoon et al., 1994; Yu and Liu, 1986/1987).
Reports have suggested that male university students consume more alcohol than female students in Western cultures (Hanson and Engs, 1990). However, the literature concerning students in Asian cultures is sparse. One study involving Chinese students in Singapore found that 72% of males and 52% of females consumed alcohol (Isralowitz and Hong, 1988).
Most reports concerning Chinese drinking patterns have been based on those living outside of China. No literature was found concerning the drinking patterns of students in the People's Republic of China in either the English or Chinese languages. In view of the fact that males consume more alcohol than females and tend to have more problems related to alcohol in other countries, this study was conducted to determine if these differences are also found among university students in one community of the People's Republic of China.
A convenience sample was used for this study. The sample consisted of undergraduate students attending Guangxi University and Guangxi National College in Nanning, the capital of Guangxi province. This predominantly ru-
The Use and Misuse of Alcohol by Chinese: Selected Parameters, Processes, and Studies____________________________________________________________________________________________
|Author||Year||Country||Data source||Data collection||Respondent/Subject||Comparison group(s)||Data collected||Results||Limitations|
|Pai||1991||USA||Healthier People (the Health Risk Appraisal Question-naire)||Convenience sample of 100 Chinese graduated students with 42% response rate||Chinese graduate students form Taiwan (R.O. C.) and China (P.R.O.C.)||Non-Chinese graduate students||Proportion of students who drink||36% of Chinese students reported drinking, 31% reported abstaining and 34% provided no information. There were no heavy drinkers. 69% of non-Chinese were drinkers and 19% were heavy drinkers||34% of Chinese respondents did not provide information on drinking|
|Chi et al.||1989||USA||Drinking behaviors based on questions from Cahalan=s quantity, Frequency, and Variability Scale||Purposive sampling based on Los Angeles (CA) telephone book||298 Chinese-Americans, 295 Japanese-Americans, and 280 Korean-Americans who completed the interviews||Japanese-American and Korean-American residents of Los Angeles (CA)||Proportions of abstainers, moderate drinkers, and heavy drinkers||Chinese-Americans had highest proportion of moderate drinkers and lowest proportion of heavy drinkers, compared to Japanese-Americans and Korean-Americans||Refusal rate not reported|
|Klatsky et al.||1977||USA||Medical treatment records||Analysis of treatment records for patients aged 15-79 for period 1964-1968||Asian patients in Kaiser-Permanente Medical Care Program||Caucasian and Afro-American patients in same medical care program||Proportions of drinkers among Asian patients, of whom 57% were Chinese||Asian sample had many more abstainers among both males and females than did comparison groups||Sample included 43% non-Chinese Asians; data are now dated|
|Yu et al.||1984||USA||1977 National Health Interview Study||Interview survey of 41,000 households nationwide||One-third subsample of persons 20 years and older||None||Drinking frequency of Asian/Pacific Americans||More Asian/Pacific Americans were abstainers than frequent drinkers (3 or more times per week)||The Asian/Pacific American category cannot be disaggregated to identify Chinese-Americans|
|Isralowitz and Hong||1986/1987||Singapore||Engs and Hanson=s Student Alcohol Questionnaire||Questionnaires mailed to stratified random sample of 1,840 students, with a 63% usable response rate||1,160 college students in Singapore (767 Chinese, 127 Maly, and 185 Indian students)||College students in Israel and the USA||Quantity and frequency of drinking as well as nature and extent of drinking problems||61% of respondents were drinkers (72% of men and 52% of women). A much lower proportion of students in Singapore reported experiencing drinking problems compared to students in Israel ant the USA||Sample included 34% non-Chinese students|
|Yu and Liu||1987||USA||Questions asked in an exploratory study of cognitive impairment||Interviews||Clients aged 50 years or older entering the Chinese-American Service League in Chicago=s Chinatown||None||Proportion of drinkers||While the proportion of abstainers was high, it decreased with advancing age||Sample (n=142) nonrandom sample|
|Sue et al.||1985||USA||Data collected but unanalyzed and unreported by Kitano and Chi (1985)||Interviews||Heads of households in Los Angeles (CA): Chinese n=298, Japanese n=288, Korean n=280||Japanese-Americans and Korean-Americans||Proportions of abstainers, moderate drinkers, and heavy drinkers||Chinese-Americans dramatically less likely to be heavy drinkers||Lack of detailed questions regarding drinking patterns, especially in relation to acculturation|
ral inland province is located in the southeastern part of the People's Republic of China. Approximately 7,000 students attended Guangxi university and about 3,500 attend Guangxi National College (Guangxi yearbook Editorial Group, 1992; Gu and Pen-Feng, 1993).
During the autumn term of the 1993-1994 academic year, students in several "study classrooms," where students are assigned to study when not attending classes, were asked to participate in the Bsurvey by the Chinese author. The students were told the study was a collaborate effort with American researchers and that responses were anonymous. The response rate was 100%. Of the 190 individuals who completed questionnaires, 55.3% were liberal arts and 44.7% were science and engineering students. In terms of class year, 37.9% were first, 48.4% second, 5.3% third, and 8.4% were fourth year students. Of the total sample, 58.5% were male and 41.5% female. The mean age was 21.1 years and ranged from 18 to 35 years of age.
Parts of the Student Alcohol Questionnaire (Engs, 1974; Engs and Hanson, 1994) were used for this study. This instrument is highly reliable and has been used by several researchers studying university students' drinking patterns in Western and Asian cultures over the past few years (Engs and Aldo-Benson, 1995; Hayworth-Hoeppner et al., 1993; Hong and Isralowitz, 1989). The reliability of the 19 items selected for the Chinese version were recalculated. The Spearman-Brown reliability coefficient was .98, Chronbach's alpha was .90, and Gutman's split half(see Table 2), the second consisted of 11 items related to drinking behaviors (See Table 3) and the third category included five items assessing attitudes toward drinking and perceived attitudes of significant others toward the respondent's alcohol consumption (see Table 4). The students completed this pencil and paper questionnaire in about 15 minutes.-half coefficient was .55. The reliability coefficients of individual items ranged from .2 to .9 for the 19 questions.
The items were grouped into three categories. The first contained three items about usual drinking patterns
Since the questions in the Chinese translation were not worded in such a way as to make possible the calculation of a quantity-frequency index. only descriptive information could be determined. Chi-square analyses were used to compare the responses of male and female students.
Limitations of the Study
Only items considered relevant to the culture by the Chinese author's department were selected. They were translated by this author and her colleagues at Guangxi Medical University into Chinese. Some items were modified to make them more appropriate. For example, "driving a car" was changed to "riding a motor bike or bike." The Chinese version was then "backtranslated" into English for comparison with the original items. In spite of this process, the same questions may not have had the same or exactly equivalent meanings in Guangxi province.
Another limitation of the study was that the sample was not randomly selected from all undergraduate students from the two universities. This convenience sample is limited to those students who were assigned to a particular study classroom and for whom permission to administer the questionnaire was granted.
Drinking Patterns of Male and Female Students
Male students in this sample reported they consumed alcohol significantly (?2 = 48.3, df = 4, p < .001) more frequently compared to females. Both males
Chi-Square Analysis Comparing the Drinking Patterns of Male and Female Students
|Usual drinking pattern||Males (%)||Females(%)|
|Frequency of drinking among all students:a|
|Once a week but not daily||19.1||7.6|
|At least once a month but less than once a week||33.6||24.4|
|Not at all||8.2||52.6|
|Type of beverage consumed by drinkers:b|
|Chinese medicine wine||28.7||13.5|
|Light wine (<15% alcohol)||5.0||5.4|
|Medium wine (15-30% alcohol)||5.9||0.0|
|Strong wine (30% alcohol)||1.0||2.7|
|Usual amount consumed by drinkers:b|
a Males, N =110, Females, N= 78.
b Males, N = 101, Females, N = 37.
+P < .05 *p < .001.
to females (see Table 2 and females reported beer as the most commonly used beverage. Chinese medicine wine or "tonic" was the second most commonly consumed alcohol beverage by both groups. Males consumed significantly (?2 = 14.4, df = 4, p < .05) more alcohol compared).
Drinking Related Behaviors and Problems Related to Alcohol
There was a significant difference between males and females (?2 = 29.1, p < .001) in the setting of their first drinking experience. However, there was no difference between gender in place or situation of usual alcohol consumption (see Table 3).
A significantly higher percentage of males reported problems resulting from drinking with the exception of "having got into trouble with the school administration" because of drinking too much.
Chi-Square Analysis Comparing the Percentage of Male (N = 101) and Female (N= 37) Students Reporting Drinking-Related Behaviors or Problems
|1. Situation of first drink:|
|With other relatives||8.5||2.9|
|2. Situation of usual consumption:|
|With other relatives||4.0||5.4|
|3. Has consumed alcohol with parents||76.2||78.4|
|4. Has consumed alcohol alone||50.5||35.1|
|Has experienced following problems related to drinking:|
|6. Nausea and vomiting||21.8||2.6*|
|7. Driving motor bike (or bike) after drinking||43.6||10.4*|
|8. Missed class because of hangover||11.8||2.6+|
|9. Been criticized by close friend because of drinking too much||23.6||3.8|
|10. Received a lower grade because of drinking too much||8.2||1.3+|
|11. Been in trouble with school administration because of drinking too much||8.2||2.6|
+p < .05; *p < .001.
Chi-Square Analyses Comparing the Percent of Male (N = 101) and Female (N = 37) University Students Reporting
Various Attitudes Toward Drinking or Perceived Attitudes of Significant Others
|Would consume alcohol if there was no social pressure to do so||19.0||2.7+|
|Would feel uneasy about acknowledging use of alcohol to a person whom they knew did not approve of its use||48.5||38.9|
|Father approves of their alcohol consumption||49.5||58.3|
|Mother approves of their alcohol consumption||41.6||54.1|
|Thought that a teacher would be displeased with them if they consumed alcohol||33.7||21.6|
+p < .05.
Attitudes and Perceived Attitudes of Significant Others
Of the five attitudinal items, only one yielded a significant (?2= 5.7, df = 1, p < .05) difference between males and females; a higher percent of males said they would Aconsume alcohol if there were no social pressure to do so (see Table 4).
The results appear to confirm previous findings of males and females in general and university students in particular. In this sample of students, as was found by Isralowitz and Hong (1988) among Chinese students in Singapore, beer was the beverage of preference. Chinese medicine wine was the next most common beverage consumed. Such wine is considered a tonic which will increase virility and health. As has been found in other studies of Chinese cultures outside the People's Republic, males were more likely to consume alcohol and to do so with greater frequency and in greater quantity consistent with other studies. Males also reported their first drinking experience with friends whereas females with family. Consistent with other studies of university students in western cultures, males also reported more problems related to alcohol compared to the female students.
The lack of differences between males and females for items concerning perceived attitudes on the part of parents and a respected authority figure toward their drinking may reflect the general acceptance of alcohol use for both sexes among this Chinese sample. These results appear to mirror earlier observations that suggest moderate alcohol consumption is widely accepted throughout Chinese culture. Alternatively, the lack of differences in perceived attitude could be reflective of the social forces which have attempted to diminish inequality between the genders over the past few decades. Given the continuing changes in Chinese society including industrial urbanization, it will be important to examine drinking-related behaviors and attitudes over time.
Dr. Engs would like to thank the following individuals and Indiana University for their help: Chun-Ying Chen for her Aback translation@ of the Chinese version of the Student Alcohol Questionnaire, and David Koceja and John V. Samuel for statistical and computer consultation. This study was funded by Indiana University and Guangxi Medical University.
AHERN, F. M. (1985). Alcohol use and abuse among four ethnic groups In Hawaii: Native Hawaiians, Japanese, Filipinos, and Caucasians. In D. Speigler, D. Tate, S. Aitken, and C. Christian (Eds.), Alcohol Abuse among U.S. Ethnic Minorities. Rockvill, MD: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, pp. 315-328.
AKUTSU, P. D., SUE, S., NOLAN, W. S. S., and NAKAMURA, C. Y. (1989). Ethnic differences in alcohol consumption among Asians and Caucasians in the United States: An investigation of cultural and physiological factors. J. Stud. Alcohol 50: 261-267.
CHI, I., KITANO, H. H. L., and LUBBEN, J. E. (1988). Male Chinese drinking behavior in Los Angeles. J. Stud. Alcohol 49: 21-25.
CHI, I., LUBBEN, J. E., and KITANO, H. H. L. (1989). Differences in drinking behavior among three Asian-American groups. J. Stud. Alcohol 50: 15-23.
ENGS, R. C. (1974). The Student Alcohol Questionnaire. Bloomington, IN.
ENGS, R. C., and ALDO-BENSON, M. (1995). The association of alcohol consumption with self- reported illness in university students, Psychol. Rep. 76: 727-736.
ENGS, R. C., and HANSON, D. J. (1994). The Student Alcohol Questionnaire: An updated reliability of the drinking patterns, problems, knowledge, and attitudes subscales. Psychol. Rep. 74: 12-14.
FEI-PENG, ZHANG (1982). Drinking in China. Drink. Drug Pract. Surv. 18: 12-15.
GRANET, M. (1957). Chinese Civilization. London: Barnes and Noble.
GU, YU-E, and PEN-FENG, Y. (1993). The Viewpoint of Different Level Leaders for Health Education Contents. Presented at the First National Ethnic Nationalities Health Education Conference of the People's Republic of China. Nanning.
GUANGXI YEARBOOK EDITORIAL GROUP (1992). Guangxi Yearbook. Nanning. 1992.
HANSON, D. J., and ENGS, R. C. (1990). Gender differences in drinking patterns and problems among college students: A review of the literature. J. Alcohol Drug Educ. 35(2).
HAYWORTH-HOEPPNER, S., GLOBETTI, G., STEM, J., and MORASCO, F. (1989). The quantity and frequency of drinking among undergraduates at a southern university. Int. J. Addict. 24: 829-857.
HELZER, J. E., CANINO, G. J., YEH, E. K., BLAND, R. C., LEE, C. K., HWU, H. G., and NEWMAN, S. (1990). Alcoholism-North America and Asia. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 47: 313- 321.
HSU, F. L. K. Americans and Chinese (1970). New York, NY: Natural History Press.
ISRALOWITZ, R., and HONG, A. T. (1988). Singapore: A study of university students' drinking behavior. Br. J. Addict. 83: 1321-1323.
KITANO, H. H. L., and CHI, I. (1985). Asian Americans and alcohol: The Chinese, Japanese, Koreans, and Filipinos in Los Angeles. In D. Spiegler, D. Tate, S. Aiken, and C. Christian (Eds.), Alcohol Abuse
among U.S. Ethnic Minorities. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, pp. 373-382.
KLATSKY, A. L., FRIEDMAN, G. D., SIEGELAUB, A. B., and GERARD, J. J. (1972). Alcohol consumption among White, Black, or Oriental men and women. Am. J. Epidemiol. 105:311-232.
LABARRE, W. (1946). Some observations on character structure in the Orient. II. The Chinese. Part Two. Psychiatry 9: 375-395.
LEMARCHAND, L., KOLONEL, L. N., and YOSHIZAWA, C. N. (1985). Alcohol consumption patterns among the five major ethnic groups in Hawaii: Correlations with the incidence of esophageal and oropharyngeal cancer. In D. Spiegler, D. Tate, S. Aiken, and C. Christian (Eds.), Alcohol Abuse among U.S. Ethnic Minorities. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, pp. 355-371.
PAI, S. M. (1991). Smoking and Alcohol Consumption Behaviors in Chinese Graduate Students and American Students: A Comparative Study. Unpublished M.S. thesis, State University of New York at Binghamton.
SAMUELSON, J. (1878). The History of Drink. London: Trubner and Co.
SUE, S., KITANO, H., HATANAKA, H., and YEUNG, W. T. (1985). Alcohol consumption among Chinese in the United States. In L. Bennett, and G. Ames (Eds.), The American Experience with Alcohol. New York, NY: Plenum, pp. 359-371.
WEATHERSPOON, A. J., DANKO, G. P., and JOHNSON, R. C. (1984). Alcohol consumption and use norms among Chinese Americans and Korean Americans. J. Stud. Alcohol 45: 203-206.
YU, E. K., LIU, W. T., and KURZEJA, P. (1984). Physical and Mental Health Status Indicators for Asian/Pacific Americans. Report Prepared for the Task Force on Black and Minority Health. Bethesda, MD: National Institute of Health.
YU, E. S. H., and LIU, W. T. (1986/1987). Alcohol use and abuse among Chinese-Americans. Alcohol Health Res. World pp. 14-17, 60-61.
YU, E. S. H., LUI, W. T., XIA, Z., and ZHANG, M. (1985). Alcohol use, abuse, and alcoholism among Chinese Americans: A review of the epidemiologic data. In D. Spiegler, D. Tate, S. Aiken, and C. Christian (Eds.), Alcohol Abuse among U.S. Ethnic Minorities. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, pp. 329-341.
*To whom reprint requests should be addressed at Poplars 615, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA.
Se dio a rellenar a una muestra de 190 estudiantes de dos universidades de Nanning, China, una traduccion al chino del Cuestionario sobre el Consumo de Alcohol por Estudiantes (Student Alcohol Questionnaire). Los varones consumian alcohol con mas frecuencia y en mayores cantidades que las hembras (diferencia significativa, p< 0.05). Una proporcion significativamente mayor de varones tambien tuvieron problemsas a causa de su consumo de bebidas alcoholicas. La cerveza era la bebida alcoholica preferida por ambos sexos. La mayoria de los estudiantes de ambos sexos bebian con sus amigos, y la mayoria tambien habia consumido bebidas alcoholicas con sus padres; aproximadamente la mitad dijeron que sus padres aprobaban su consumo de alcohol. Los resultados apoyan las abservaciones hechas anteriormente de que el consumo moderado de bebidas aldcoholicas esta aceptado ampliamente en la cultura china y de que produce pocos problems.
Traduit en chinois, le Questionnaire sur la consommation d'alcool en milieu etudiants, a ete complete par 190 etudiants de deux universites de Nanning en Chine.
Les etudiants de sexe masculin consomment de l'alcool beaucoup plus frequemment et en plus grande quantite que les etudiants de sexe feminin. Une proportion plus importante d'etudiants masculins semble presenter quelques troubles de comportement apres avoir consomme de l'alcool. La biere est la boisson alcoolisee de choix pour les etudiants des deux sexes. La plupart des studiants boivent avec leurs amis et consomment en compagnie de leurs parents; a peu pres la moitie des etudiants indiquent que leurs parents n'objectent pas a ce qu'ils consomment de l'alcool.
Les resultats de l'etudes viennent appuyer les observations preliminaires selon lesquelles une consommation moderee d'alcool est acceptee a grande echelle dans la culture chinoise, et entraine des troubles de comportement moindres.
Zhuo-Ping Lu is a lecturer in the Department of Hygiene at Guangxi Medical University, in Nanning, Guanxi Province of the People's Republic of China. She has a medical degree from that university with a focus in pediatrics. She is interested in international health education and collaborative research with other countries.
Ruth C. Engs, Professor of Applied Health Science, Indiana University, Bloomington, is the author of numerous publications. In 1995 she was editor for a special issue of Addiction Research: Alcohol Use in Cultural and Historical Perspectives. Since the mid-1970s she has accomplished widely cited research of university students drinking patterns and health issues in several cultures. She and David Hanson have jointly examined trends in drinking among collegians in the United States.
David J. Hanson is Professor of Sociology at the State University of New York at Potsdam. He is the author of over 275 publications, one of the most recent being Preventing Alcohol Abuse: Alcohol, Culture and Control. His research is reported in textbooks in over a dozen disciplines. Since the early 1980s he has collaborated with Ruth Engs on nationwide longitudinal research of drinking patterns and problems among university and college students.